| |
"Change? What do you mean "change"?
Changes in Our Lives and in the History of Christian Belief
presented by Stephenie Rose Cooper
Session 2, continued: Christianity and Islam, East and West
History of Christianity*
7 C.E. Jesus preaches in the temple
27 John the Baptist and Jesus begin their ministries,
29 John the Baptist beheaded by Herod.
30 Jesus crucified and resurrected.
31 Gamaliel, head of the Sanhedrin, encourages tolerance of the Christians.
33 Steven stoned (first martyr)
34 Paul persecutes the Christians but undergoes conversion
49 Council of Jerusalem deals with the subject of
Gentiles in the church. James--not Peter--issues a decree that the Gentiles are relieved from following the Torah and becoming circumcised. 49 Claudius expels the Jews from Rome as tension between orthodox and Christian Jews flares up in violence.
50-52 Books of 1st and 2nd Thessalonians written. The Virgin Mary dies in Ephesus at age 64 (?); Catholic tradition will assert that she undergoes an immediate resurrection and is assumed into Heaven. Possibly Matthews Gospel is written in Aramaic, to be followed by a Greek translation after marks Gospel makes use of it.
64 Rome burns; Nero blames the Christians and severe
persecution begins. Book of Acts written. Matthias stoned to death. 85 Nicolaitans sect promotes a number of false doctrines; lasting impact will be to greatly
elevate the priesthood above the laity which will give birth to the Catholic and Orthodox hierarchies. 100 John, last of the Apostles, dies in Ephesus.
107 Simeon, bishop of Jerusalem and last verifiable relative of Jesus, martyred at the ripe old age of 120. First recorded use of the term
"Catholic church" by Ignatius. 125 First recorded instance of a prayer to Mary.
200 Christian ministers for the first time are called
priests . 260 First datable instance of Christians praying to the saints (Peter & Paul) for intercession.
300 By this point, only the clergy are permitted to speak from the pulpit (in earlier centuries both clergy and lay people were permitted to teach the Scriptures).
312 Constantine superficially converts to Christianity after a dream leads him to a military victory. He remains polytheistic until his death, even striking coins to honor Apollo.
321 Constantine declares Sunday the official Christian sabbath day.
325 Council of Nicea meets to codify Christian doctrines in response to growing heresies--Jewish bishops are specifically excluded from the meeting.
Doctrine of the Trinity formally acknowledged--in some cases with bishops threatened with death if they do not accept it. 337 Christianity becomes the official state religion of Rome. Constantine finally receives baptism as a Christian (from heretical Arian priests) and dies on Pentecost.
338 Jewish calendar converted to solar calendar.
431 Council of Ephesus formally acknowledges Mary is the mother of God and that Jesus was God in the flesh.
451 Council of Chalcedon gives the same authority to the Bishop of Constantinople as to the bishop of Rome; this is the beginning of the eventual schism between the Eastern and Western churches.
460 Pope Leo forbids priests to marry
476 Fall of the Roman Empire
625 Mohammad begins the Koran
1054 The Eastern and Roman church separate with both popes excommunicating each other.
1208 St. Francis of Assisi renounces wealth to follow Christ.
1215 Marriage declared to be a sacrament and now requires the consent of both parties
1232 Pope Gregory IX appoints the first inquisitors.
1348-1351 Bubonic plague kills 33% of Europeans; blamed on Avignon papacy, Jews, personal immorality
1382 John Wyclif publishes the first English Bible translated from the Vulgate.
1453 Constantinople falls to the Moslems.
1456 Gutenberg Bible printed.
1478 Spanish Inquisition begun by King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella, resulting in the deaths of tens of thousands, including Jews.
1508 Martin Luther has the revelation that a man is saved by faith in Christ alone, apart from either works or the Sacraments.
1517 Luther nails his 95 theses to the door of the Castle Church at Wittenberg.
1532 Church of England breaks away from Rome, presumably because the Church of Rome has strayed so far from the original faith
1545 Council of Trent forms to respond to the schism started by Luther, eventually ratifying a number of key doctrines which affect the Catholic church to this day. Included are: Faith alone is not sufficient for salvation; Scripture and tradition hold equal value; the seven Sacraments are necessary for salvation; Transubstantiation formally acknowledged; priests forbidden to marry; Catholic canon of Scripture formally ratified.
1562 Gregorian calendar introduced, changing the New Year from April 1 to January 1.
1609 The Baptist church founded in opposition to infant baptism.
1611 First appearance of the King James Bible.
1633 Galileo is forced to renounce his teachings.
1637 Scottish Prayer books adds words "For thine is the Kingdom" etc. to the Lords Prayer no record of this ending prior to this date
1830s 1860s Oxford Movement crosses the Atlantic to the U.S. Prior to this, the following were not permitted in the American Episcopal Church:
candles on the altar
church statuary
elaborate vestments
holy water
incense
sung services
Latin and/or Greek in the services
calling the clergyman "father"
veneration of the reserved sacrament
crossing one's self
1950s Blacks and women are permitted to serve as delegates to National Convention of the Episcopal Church
1976 General Convention of the Episcopal Church approves the ordination of women
1988 - Barbara Harris first woman to be elected a bishop in the Anglican Communion -- suffragen for Diocese of Massachusetts
1993 - Mary Adelia McLeod first women elected to be a diocesan bishop in the Episcopal Church -- ordinary for the Diocese of Vermont
And so it goes
*Primary source: http://www.centralcal.com/crist1.htm
Christian Assumptions About
God Today-- Colin Chapman, The Case for Christianity
God is Personal
God is Infinite
God is Creator
God is Sustainer
God is Loving
God is Holy
There is only One God
There are three "Persons" in the One God
Jesus spoke about himself as the Son
Jesus spoke about the Holy Spirit as distinct from himself and the Father
Early Christians experienced God working in their lives in a radically new way and they understood this to be the work of the Holy Spirit.
Christian Assumptions about
Salvation-- Colin Chapman, The Case for Christianity
God must judge but wants to forgive
Forgiveness is available to all
Death means more than physical death
Forgiveness is always something costly
If men bear the consequences of their sin and guilt, it means death
Man cannot solve his problems by himself
Grace is achieved by faith
"It is a distinguishing characteristic of Christianity not that it preaches a God of love, but that it preaches a God of conscience " B. B. Warfield, American Theologian
Christian Assumptions about
Jesus-- Colin Chapman, The Case for Christianity
Fully human and fully divine
His death achieved something he was bearing our sins
We can be reasonably certain that he rose from the dead
"Even if we had the best film of a Jerusalem newsreel of the year 30 A.D., it would not help us much since it could not show us what really happened on that day proof cannot be given of Jesus resurrection God exposes himself to skepticism, doubt and disbelief, renouncing anything that would compel men to believe assurance grows out of life with the word of the risen Lord and in obedience to Him." Eduard Schweitzer
"Faith in the resurrection should be based on the faith of the first disciples."
God and Science
John Shelby Spong, Why Christianity Must Change or Die
16th C.
Newton demonstrated that there were natural explanations for things that had beenconsidered mysteries
The universe operated according to fixed laws, which brooked no interference from any external source, divine or otherwise
Growing fear that there may be no intervening power capable of or eager to respond to our deep yearnings
Work of Charles Darwin took the rug out from under the notion that human beings were the crown of Gods creation
The work of creation not yet finished
Concept of life after death began to wobble
In the face of todays truths, believers must find new meaning for the reality of God or the reality of God will die
Paradigm Shift Spongs New Reformation
|
Shift From |
Shift To |
| The earth is at the center; the sky is the roof and earth is the floor | The Universe is infinite; there is no center |
| God is external, personal, supernatural | God is within, at the depth of being; a revitalizing force with no boundaries |
| Heaven is "up there" and hell is "below" | Heaven is a state of being; there is no hell |
| Humanity is the purpose of creation | Humanity may not be the end of creation |
| Sickness is result of sin being punished | Sickness is just part of life |
| The purpose of the written creed was to clarify truth | The purpose of the written creed was to rule out opposing points of view |
| The virgin birth was literal | The virgin birth was legendary |
| Jesus is God incarnate; Mary was God-bearer | God was within Christ; Jesus had special access to the God within In Jesus, God and human life were seen to flow together; Jesus life was not bound by traditional limits. There was in him a transcendence, a holiness that only God could have created. Jesus was God-bearer |
| The resurrection was literal | The resurrection was metaphorical Jesus a spirit-person spirit presence of Jesus transcended death and was now a reality that manifested in his disciples |
Symbols of our Changing Theology
Altars have come out from facing the walls and celebrants now face the people
Altar facing external deity now faces the people; God is perceived as being present in the people
People are rising from their knees
Kneeling was the approach of a serf or beggar
Experimental liturgies are proliferating
Finding new expression for the depth of the divine
Revisions in prayer books
No longer reflect concept as sin being a punishment, childbirth making a woman unclean, that weather can be changed by human petition, that God is on the side of only one nation
Change in view of ordained ministers
Paternal priestly power of antiquity eroding, ordained person not someone who stands between the theistic God above and the fragile human below
Spong suggests that in the future, lay persons may preside at the Eucharist
The Future Church
We will still worship its the way we practice self-definition
Will be marked by the awareness that we are all God-bearers
Scriptures will be treasured as a record of the faith of ancestors, but worship will not be bound by cultural or cultic limitations of the scriptures
Christ will not be seen as the exclusive path
No denigrating or judging of other religious traditions; Christ will be an inviting presence
Ceremony that transforms ordinary elements into body and blood will not survive
But the communal meal will survive feeding one another is the experience in which life, love and being are shared; the common meal is a holy act
There is something real beyond the limits of this life
<Steph>Are we on the brink of being able to communicate with whatever is beyond death?</Steph>
Spong: "Making it possible for everyone else to live, to love, and to be is the only mission that Christian people possess."
"When my being is enhanced by love, called to a new reality by love, introduced through love to limitless freedom, then I believe I have touched what is timeless, eternal and real. My confidence in eternal life, life beyond the finitude and death, is found in that experience, and my doorway into that experience is still the one who, for me, seems to have embodied it, Jesus whom I call Christ."
Lennon: "All you need is love."
Paradigm Shift The Cosmic Christ
-- Matthew Fox
|
Shift From |
Shift To |
| Anthropomorphism | Living Cosmology |
| Newton | Einstein |
| Parts-mentality | Wholeness, holistics |
| Rationalism | Mysticism |
| Obedience as prime moral virtue | Creativity as prime moral virtue |
| Personal salvation through individual behavior and a direct relationship with God | Communal healing, i.e. compassion as salvation |
| Theism (God outside us) | Panentheism (God in us and us in God) |
| Centered on the Fall and Redemption | Creation-centered |
| Religion | Spirituality |
| Ascetic | Aesthetic |
Thoughts from Dinesh DSouza
Book: Whats So Great About America
In 1995 Francis Fukuyama theorized that weve reached the "end of history" the end result being liberal, capitalist democracy
In 1997 Samuel Huntington warned that the West should not arrogantly assume that the rest of the world would embrace the principles of Judeo-Christian civilization; disputed thesis of "end of history".
"Know your enemy." Islam is not the enemy, but to understand September 11, 2001 and the fundamentalist faction we are dealing with, we must understand Islam.
Some differences between West (Christian-based) and Islam
|
West |
Islam |
| Places priority on freedom | Places priority on virtue |
| People rule | God rules |
| Strong individualism | Individualism borders on immoral self-interest contrary to will of Allah |
| Reason is a more reliable source of truth | Revelation is a more reliable source of truth |
| Historical effort to transcend ethnocentricism | Historically isolationist; no curiosity about what is not Islam |
| Universe is rational and operates according to laws | Reason and logic useless because Allah intervenes and breaks the rules of science |
Digression: Rise of Individualism in Christianity
Why did individualism take hold in the West but not the Middle East?
One theory: "Structures of church and feudalism took a major blow in the form of the Black Death, the bubonic plague. It first swept through Europe around 1350 AD, killing about a third of the total population. People of the times were accustomed to interpreting such events as acts of God, but this seemed utterly senseless. The church and the nobility were both powerless to stop it, and the rapid decline in population destabilized many aspects of the social structure. Nor could it be seen as a great purification since social behavior seemed to turn worse as a result. Those who survived, emerged with a deep-rooted belief in individual self-reliance - in a world gone crazy, it was each person for him/herself." -- Robert Gilman
East vs. West, Islam vs. Christianity
Islam paradigm is that all must be Islam and infidels must be obliterated (= jihad).
American paradigm is separation of church and state; in Islam, the church and state are one, the American paradigm is subversive
Islam covers administration of state, laws for divorce, inheritance its a complete framework for life impossible to practice in a secular framework.
Christian framework could cover all aspects of life, but when the Gentiles were exempted from following the Jewish law, it ceased to be a complete framework for daily life
Americans presuppose that free speech and equal rights are best way of organizing society and try to use such arguments when dialoging with Muslims; ineffective because for Islam, religious truth and virtue have higher claims.
Understanding History
The West once controlled 85% of resources in heyday of colonialism. The West represents a failure of
virtue, the highest value in Islam. To understand the people of Iraq, Iran, Syria, Saudi Arabia, etc. we must also understand the history of the Middle East, including the events of the Crusades, the impact of the creation of the state of Israel.
Will not try to tackle this in this class!
Next
Personal Paradigms Exercise in preparation for Session 3,
After doing exercise: Personal Paradigms